Put the two quotes side by side
Work through the points below with both quotes open. The aim isn’t to find the cheapest — it’s to make sure you’re comparing like for like, so the price actually reflects the work you’re getting.
| What to compare | What to check |
|---|---|
| Length and finished height | Where does the new fence start and end? What will its finished height be, including the gravel board, and how will it follow any slope? |
| Fence construction | Which panel style or board construction is included — featheredge, closeboard or lap? See our guide to choosing a fence style. |
| Posts | Will the posts be timber or concrete? Compare timber and concrete posts before deciding. |
| Gravel boards and capping | Does the price include gravel boards and capping? These affect the finished height and how the fence meets the ground. |
| Access and putting things back | How will materials reach the garden? If a gate or trellis needs to come down for access, who will refit it? |
| Removal of old concrete | What happens to the old posts and concrete? Is breaking out and lifting the old concrete included? |
| Disposal | Is taking the old fencing waste away included in the total, or charged separately? |
| Total payable | What is the final amount payable, including VAT where applicable? When are payments due? |
| Guarantees | What does the workmanship and material guarantee cover, and for how long? |

Completed closeboard fencing showing the timber panel, slotted concrete posts, rock-faced concrete gravel board and decorative trellis topper fitted together.
Why finished height matters
A nominal 5 ft 6 in panel on a 6 in gravel board finishes at 6 ft. A 6 ft panel on the same board finishes at 6 ft 6 in. If the run meets a gate or your neighbour’s fence, those six inches can make a noticeable difference. While the installer is there, ask them to point out exactly where the finished top will sit — ideally beside an existing gate so you can see the line.
Not sure whether your planned fence height needs planning permission? See our guide to fence planning permission in Oxfordshire.
A quick note on overlap panels
If one quote specifies budget overlap panels and another specifies closeboard panels, ask both installers to price the style you want. That makes the totals easier to compare. For a fuller comparison of styles, see our guide to choosing a fence style.
Can sections of your fence stay?
Where sound posts and rails can be retained, a targeted repair may cost far less than a full replacement. For a breakdown of when a repair is worthwhile, see our fence repair service and the repair-or-replace guidance there.
Guarantees and warranty
When comparing guarantees, ask what each covers and for how long. See our workmanship and materials warranty for what we cover — including our 12-month workmanship guarantee and the Jacksons 25-year rot guarantee.
A message you can send before accepting a quote
“Thanks for the quote. Could you confirm the fence style, finished height including the gravel board, and which posts you’ve allowed for? Is removal and disposal included, and is there anything that could change the total once work starts?”
Once you have those answers, look at the prices again. The lower quote may cover everything you want — or the extra money may buy a finish you prefer. Either way, you’ll know exactly what you’re agreeing to.

